The nature of quilting implies a coming together of disparate elements to create a pleasing and cohesive whole. Rachel Clark’s quilt, These Colors Should Run, utilizes these formal qualities to reimagine the American flag, conveying an unsettling and paradoxical image of a nation in disrepair. Clarke is a Professor at Syracuse University’s School of Information Studies whose research focuses on reconceptualizing librarianship into a design profession to better prepare libraries for the 21st century.[i] Coupled with her research interests is a passion for quilting. Her work has been displayed in numerous exhibitions, quilt shows, and festivals throughout the United States. In 2021, These Colors Should Run (2021), won the Jurors’ Choice Award Winner at the ARTQUILTS going forward exhibition sponsored by The Professional Art Quilters Alliance-South.
The American flag, in its original form, presents a highly organized design. The horizontal and alternating red and white stripes provide the visual foundation for the flag and the symbolic foundation for the nation, supporting fifty white stars housed in a field of blue. Red symbolizes hardiness and valor; white, purity and innocence; and blue, vigilance, perseverance, and justice.[ii] In her haunting reinterpretation, Clarke complicates this ordered visual in terms of reconfiguring the composition along with the mental image, or idea, that the American flag evokes.
The American flag is a sacred symbol that signifies the country’s past, present, and future. It forces one to recall her battles for independence, the birth of a liberal democracy, the countless lives lost in her defense, our inalienable rights, ceaseless fights for equality, the formation of established values and traditions, and the culminating of a fully formed nation that promises life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for all her inhabitants. The “desecration” of this sacred symbol—a contentious issue dating to the early 20th century that still holds relevancy—displays an act of symbolic speech. Clarke’s symbolic act signifies a provocative, yet beautifully poetic gesture admissible by the very symbol she redesigns.
Compositionally, the quilted flag is predominantly white. Modest geometric fragments of blue resemble shattered glass while feeble red stripes convey an equally disquieting note. “This quilt,” Clarke states “represents the (lack of) gender and racial diversity in the US Senate during the 116th Congress” (2019-2021). Every blue triangle in the star field represents a female senator; the red stripes represent the proportion of non-white senators.”[iii] Red and blue, once equally prominent and offering a sense of harmony within the original, lose their sense of vitality in Clarke’s interpretation. In their diminished state, these colors reflect the marginalized and the unheard, which serves to underscore the work’s uneasy tension.
Perpetuating further tensions is the frieze-like pillowed fabric resembling an oozing discharge from that of a wound, which contrasts sharply with the quilt’s uneven horizontal bands. Running from weakened, yet taut red strips of fabric, one can infer that the white discharge not only references a predominantly white male run Congress, but stems from a wounded, bleeding nation, a nation that has witnessed a rise in white nationalist groups, the emergence of a Black Lives Matter movement, an insurrection on our nation’s Capital, an overflow of disinformation, a floundering educational system, harrowing numbers of mass shootings, a widening wealth gap, increased polarization, and a misremembering of America’s past that has perpetuated a fictionized post-racial present. If one were to consider the works’ aliveness and predict the outcome of its continuous seepage, the white discharge would soon engulf the few red stripes that remain, erasing one of the very elements that lends the work its alluring magnetism. The work’s transformation into a dull homogenous whole would coax an infectious and uniform way of seeing with no alternative subjectivities to complicate or supplement the composition’s projected worldview.
But not all is lost, for the act of quilting is a delicate one, one that—like all art forms— requires tender patience and an understanding of the medium. Clarke’s stated “aim” is “to further blur the line between art and craft, old and young, science and emotion, and the individual and the community.”[iv] Through quilt making, Clarke offers a unifying and reparative gesture. Notwithstanding heart ache, the “tangible” and functional qualities of her work convey the comfort of reassurance and affectionate warmth, bringing a sense of calm to uncertain times. The critical message of These Colors Should Run, thus, not only illuminates Congress’s unacceptable lack of diversity, but suggests a process of healing, where the metaphor of stitching symbolically mends a divided nation.
Aside from Clarke’s role as artist/practitioner, her current profession aligns with that of a facilitator. At the heart of her work is a librarian’s spirit to organize and disseminate information. “Motivated by the juxtaposition of modern themes with traditional textile techniques,” Clarke wishes “to provoke viewers and users into seeing new and alternative perspectives,” in turn, creating new ways of understanding.[v] The creative transformation of “hard data” to “soft textiles,” enables Clarke “to visualize information in a tangible, visceral way with the ultimate goal of introducing quilting to digital natives and technological provocations to quilters of traditional demographics.”[vi]
Yet, her work extends beyond mere instruction. As an ominous forewarning of threats to democracy, These Colors Should Run offers an alternative narrative of patriotism in material form, asking us to partake in critical reflection. Albeit at times unwelcome, her quilt acts as a sympathetic and helpful guide to a more equitable and accepting future while acknowledging it a painful process. In a nation whose dissatisfaction with democracy grows, her work, however, brings a softness to the “visceral” tensions on display, tensions that recall the emotive rationale behind the recent acts of iconoclasm against Confederate monuments [vii]. As an allusion to hope and possibility, These Colors Should Run emanates an elusive sensibility that awakens an array of sensations from melancholy to revelation, thereby presenting a palpable visual rhetoric that embodies affective politics and rekindles one’s sense of civic duty. The quilt forces us to constantly question, rework, and re-define what our mental image of America is and what we want it to become. The “desecration”—or rather, a skillful reimagining—of the American flag paradoxically reflects a re-sanctification of a sacred symbol, one that we all wish to see uphold its founding principles. Reaffirming this lofty aim is the work’s loaded title; terminating in the word Run, which extends itself to the directional flow of a liquid, a form of physical exertion, management, and the political arena, the implied communal nature of These Colors Should Run demands that we—colors—run together in the pursuit of life, liberty, and happiness to create a better, less pernicious world.
[i] Rachel Ivy Clarke, “Toward a Design Epistemology for Librarianship,” The Library Quarterly 88, no. 1 (2018): 41–59, https://doi.org/10.1086/694872.
[ii] “History of the American Flag,” PBS, Public Broadcasting Service, June 27, 2022, https://www.pbs.org/a-capitol-fourth/history/old-glory/.
[iii] “Art Quiltsgoing Forward – Paqa-South,” PAQA, accessed January 19, 2023, https://www.paqa-south.org/artquiltsgoing-forward.
[iv] Rachel Ivy Clarke, “Art and Design.” Accessed January 19, 2023. http://archivy.net/ivywp/art-and-design/.
[v] Clarke, “Art and Design.”
[vi] Clarke, “Art and Design.”
[vii] Richard Wike, et. al., “Social Media Seen as Mostly Good for Democracy Across Many Nations, but U.S. is a Major Outlier.” Pew Research Center. December, 6, 2022. https://www.pewresearch.org/global/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2022/12/PG_2022.12.06_Online-Civic-Engagement_REPORT.pdf
Works Cited
“Art Quiltsgoing Forward – Paqa-South.” PAQA. Accessed January 19, 2023. https://www.paqa-south.org/artquiltsgoing-forward.
Clarke, Rachel Ivy. “Art and Design.” Accessed January 19, 2023. http://archivy.net/ivywp/art-and-design/.
Clarke, Rachel Ivy. “Toward a Design Epistemology for Librarianship.” The Library Quarterly 88, no. 1 (2018): 41–59. https://doi.org/10.1086/694872.
“History of the American Flag.” PBS. Public Broadcasting Service. June 27, 2022. https://www.pbs.org/a-capitol-fourth/history/old-glory/.